web analytics

IDEA 2009: Social and Experience Design – Day 1

I’m in Toronto this week for IDEA 2009, the conference run by the Information Architecture Institute. This year’s theme is Social and Experience Design. Speakers from a variety of backgrounds are helping us understand how to make informed and insightful design decisions based on the ever-changing landscape of the web caused in large part by social media.

Day 1 featured a great lineup:

My Twitter notes from the conference are below. Enjoy!


Luke Wroblewski

  • Luke W @lukewdesign is up now talking about the Impact of Social Models. http://bit.ly/uKniF
  • @lukewdesign talking about the project in the 80s to reduce crime in NYC by removing subway cars with graffiti.
  • “Broken windows” theory suggests that our behavior is shaped by our environment. This was discussed in Gladwell’s Tipping Point
  • The Power of Context. Small features of context can produce huge diff in behavior. So how are online social models shaping behavior?
  • @lukewdesign showing Idiots of Ants’ “Facebook in Real Life” video: http://bit.ly/FfAWK Hilarious!
  • Social relationships modeled online: 1) no relationship, 2) community, 3) groups (public, semi-public, private)…
  • …4) Symmetrical/2-way, 5) Asymmetrical/1-way (permissioned/blocked)
  • These are the social models that are out there. @lukewdesign asks, “Are there differences in contribution for each of these models?”
  • @lukewdesign loose stat: 480% jump in contribution when relationships increase by 20
  • No relationship model refers to any two people on the web using the same product even when there’s no explicit connection b/w them
  • Ex of community (1-to-many relationship) is Yahoo! Answers. 700k askers, 550k answerers. Found one connected component of 1.2M nodes
  • In a community, 1% are creators, 10% are curators, 100% are consumers. On Wikipedia 1.8% of the users write 70% of the articles
  • Group (1-to-many relationship) is a set of people within a community. They can be relationship-based (events, assoc) or topical
  • Relationship-based groups have more messages but they’re much broader set of topics. Topical participation is by fewer people
  • Groups are listed (found through search) and unlisted (invite only). Open, restricted (diff levels of access), or closed (moderator)
  • Symmetrical model is confirmed and controlled by both sides. It’s a handshake. Can be used to mirror real world relationships.
  • In a symmetrical model, when either side severs, relationship is gone, often without notification.
  • 10% of users account for 30% of production. 12% of FB users update status daily. 40% in last 7 days.
  • Asymmetrical model is fan/follow, declared by 1 side w/o reciprocation. Supports multiple relationship structures, often more public
  • “The asymmetrical model is really simple on the surface, just choose to follow someone, but there’s a lot going on underneath.”
  • Y! Messenger is an example of permissioned 1-way model. A sends B request. B accepts, then A has to accept.
  • On Twitter, 10% of users account for 90% of production. Check out more on his blog: http://www.lukew.com/ff/entry.asp?884
  • Relationship limits exist: 120 avg # of friends per FB user. 92.4% of Twitter users follow less than 100 ppl
  • Dunbar number: people can only maintain connections with approx 148 people http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar’s_number
  • Tight knit circles flourish. 90% of Twitter user’s “friends” reciprocate attention by being friends as well (2 1-way relationships)
  • So many #s in @lukewdesign‘s talk! I’m interested in all of these for a project I’m working on, but can’t capture them all this fast
  • 1-way relationships optimize for reach. Having followers encourages contribution and builds audiences. Allows messages to amplify
  • 90% of FB page’s fans can be part of a single connected group. 15% of all fans arrived independently and started their own chain
  • These patterns hold for pages with few thousands of fans as well as those with more than 50,000 fans. Pretty amazing statistic
  • Hey everyone, it’s NOT @lukew, it’s @lukewdesign. Pass it on!

Leisa Reichelt

  • Leisa Reichelt @leisa is up now giving a talk titled “Bare Naked Design: Reflections on Designing with an Open Source Community”
  • @leisa is talking about her experience working on the Drupal 7 UX project http://www.d7ux.org/
  • @leisa showing her We Need You! intro video to the Drupal 7 UX project http://bit.ly/wn9EA
  • They told the Drupal community: “We want your rejection…urgently.” Takes a very humble designer to do that. Impressive
  • @leisa says: “Community is the design challenge.” Something we all need to internalize
  • Some folks who use Drupal: recovery.gov, IxDA, The Economist, Sony BMG & more. Not just a geek platform. But not known for good UX
  • @leisa‘s partner on the Drupal 7 UX project is @markboulton. He’s not at the conference, but deserves the props as well
  • “I don’t think there’s anyone who can claim to have been successful at integrating UX and dev on an open source project” — @leisa
  • @leisa describing the evolution of the D7UX project, talking about the various methods they used and whether they were successful
  • “We were spending upwards of 80% of our time just communicating.” Very little time actually designing. That can be frustrating
  • HA! http://www.d7ux.org/ is a WordPress blog. “We didn’t have the time or the skills to set up Drupal.” — @leisa HA HA
  • Video wasn’t just a broadcast for them, but was an interactive media for them. Used for crowdsourced usability testing
  • They created a usability testing kit for users to go out and conduct their own tests on their Drupal site, showed how using video
  • @Fusebox‘s http://lockerblogger.com uses Drupal
  • @bnunnally — My disciples!
  • D7UX: success or failure? @leisa not showing screenshots cuz that’s too surface level. Does it look prettier? Yes. But is it better?
  • @leisa not confident that the improvements will be long-lasting. D7 might not have better learning curve than previous versions
  • Many things that @leisa & @markboulton wanted to achieve didn’t make their way into the redesign. That’s life. But project worth it
  • Some things @leisa has learned: 1. It’s not designers vs. developers that’s the problem, it’s Framework vs Product. AMAZING QUOTE
  • @leisa just gave me the words I’ve always been looking for. I just exhaled
  • 2. Designing in the open is a great thing to do for your peers. We don’t often get to see each other’s work.
  • 3. It’s possible to survive sporadic personal attacks for 6 months without going totally bonkers.
  • Join http://www.designintheopen.org/ “A community of practice for design & user experience people in Open Source”
  • Agreed! Makes me wish I’d done more outreach w @boxee. RT @emenel: Great presentation from @leisa on open source ux. v inspirational

Thomas Malaby

  • Up next is Thomas Malaby from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee on “Making Virtual Worlds: Games & the Human for a Digital Age”
  • Learn more about Thomas Malaby at http://www.uwm.edu/~malaby/
  • “Games are good at creating contrived openness” — Thomas Malaby. Hope I got that quote right
  • Because games are persistent and open-ended, people can accumulate social capital and credentials. He’s referring to MMORPGs
  • @bnunnally I don’t even know what that means!
  • Thomas Malaby is on Twitter @tmmalaby, but he’s protected
  • Game built to prompt social experience along the way until you reach the endgame which is an individual experience. Sounds like life
  • @tmmalaby showing this photo: http://bit.ly/ceutq So cool!
  • Philip Rosedale, Founder of Linden Lab: “I didn’t go in feeling like we’re going to make people’s lives better…
  • …But I did go into it feeling like none of it was interesting unless there were a lot of people involved.”
  • RT @orian #idea09 what I think is missing w Second Life is ultimately it’s a private entity. There needs to be an open version (AOL vs web)
  • Really wish this stuff resonated w me. I see the relevance, just doesn’t reach me. Maybe my feelings about gamers turns my brain off
  • Check out Malaby’s book: Making Virtual Worlds http://bit.ly/1s0uFS
  • This stuff makes me think of Prof Randy Pausch. RIP
  • @orian & I are working on a Twitter app together. Join him for lunch today to share your insights on usage patterns & feature ideas

Christina Wodtke

  • Christina Wodtke @cwodtke is up now talking about Social Spaces Online: Lessons from Radical Architects
  • Is online the new “3rd place”? We’ve got home, office and ____. Used to be in the physical space, but that’s gone away
  • @cwodtke talking about Frank Lloyd Wright’s Imperial Palace made earthquake proof http://bit.ly/K2nYX
  • “Social earthquakes” at LinkedIn: recruiters who spam groups with jobs can be handled with a “Move to Jobs” link or “Report as spam”
  • Prepare for technical execution, maintenance, scale and bandwidth; social innocents/idiots, trolls, spammers, criminals
  • Essentially @cwodtke is saying that there are social patterns we need to be aware of and design for them
  • “Early in life I had to chosen between honest arrogance and hypocritical humility…
  • …I chose honest arrogance and have seen no occasion to change.” – Frank Lloyd Wright
  • Delight: “when the appearance of the work is pleasing and in good taste…
  • …and when its members are in due proportion according to correct principles of symmetry.”
  • @cwodtke recommends following community architect @Amyjokim
  • @cwodtke‘s slide showing the Nn/g crew http://mypict.me/EfXo
  • @cwodtke going through her list of radical architects and their lessons
  • Space. Here’s @cwodtke‘s model for shaping social space http://mypict.me/EgoC
  • Site: location affects the nature of what we build. Online, context=site. What we’re building on determines shape of the experience
  • Structure: the materials we use have a shape & nature that yearn for a certain implementation. They will affect our users’ behavior
  • Speed. Think about how fast people are experiencing your product. When theyre signing up, let them fly through. Then speed up gently
  • Movement. @cwodtke showing Frank Gehry’s Dancing House http://bit.ly/lKwv5 Design with composition principles

Mary Newsom

  • Up now Mary Newsom on The Information Superhighway: Urban Renewal or Neighborhood Destruction? She’s assoc ed for Charlotte Observer
  • I’m very confused by this chart. What’s the sample? Were the same people polled each time? http://mypict.me/EhkA
  • I love people from other disciplines, but I’m not seeing the connection here. Can someone clue me in?
  • Wow. And now we’re talking about death panels.
  • I disagree. Tweets about good burritos are very relevant to me. Do you know how hard it is to find a good burrito in NYC?!
  • Mary Newsom leaves us with: “Maybe you get what you pay for.” I hear you, but sometimes what you pay for is packaged drivel
  • RT @livlab: journalists: pls defend your awesome journalism, but let go of the medium! it’s the medium that isn’t working, not you!

Maya Kalman

  • Up now is event/experience planner Maya Kalman on Does Designing a Social Experience Affect How We Party? Of Course It Does!
  • Awww Maya is using the logo for the wrong IDEA conference :)
  • Event design is about creating experiences. Social gatherings are “far more than a collection of events…”
  • An event planner matches client’s wants, goals and needs to a target audience. Sound familiar?
  • “The real mark of an event planner is to be able to control uncontrollable circumstances.” — Maya Kalman. Well said
  • “Events are unpredictable, so always have a contingency plan. And sometimes a contingency for your contingency.”
  • “You don’t have to believe in feng shui to understand that your surroundings contribute to your experience.”
  • Maya Kalman talking about the quality of surroundings: “I’m a city girl, but my husband is from New Hampshire…unfortunately.”
  • RT @bnunnally Good design puts us at ease and helps us relax. We know the creators are trying to take care of our needs.
  • RT @bnunnally: Good design removes barriers and allows people to be more social and open.
  • Leaving guests in one area often tires them and bores them. More movement = more dynamic event. Makes them feel like more happened
  • THIS is how you take a tangential practice and make it relevant for us. THANK YOU Maya Kalman
  • “I like to know that I’ve arrived at an event and immediately feel immersed in it.” Just a focus to answering a simple question
  • Lightbulbs are going off over my head in full force. I need a transcript of this presentation. We consultants need these analogies!
  • “People eat with their eyes…and that doesn’t always pertain to food.”
  • “Moments of luxury” when you transport your guests to another place & time like they’re truly the VIPs in the room. Socialize w ease
  • Invitation sets the tone and focus of the event. Connects guests to the social experience by having to act
  • Maya Kalman’s company Swank sent a single Manolo Blahnik shoe as invite & said you’ll get the other shoe when you RSVP Yes. AMAZING
  • “If you want to get people talking, have them wear nametags.”
  • “It’s all about the little details…that’s what people talk about.” Reminds me of @armano‘s Micro Interactions
  • Presentation is everything. Well thought out and done with style. Gives everything a higher sense of value.
  • “Better off doing fewer elements well than doing lots of things mediocrely.” So people in other industries believe that too? Phew!
  • @russu It’s so comforting, isn’t it?
  • Holy crap! @adamhirsch of @mashable just got a shoutout by Maya Kalman. Hi Adam!
  • RT @livlab Event design safety concerns are equal to business rules in web design
  • Maya Kalman’s talk kicked ass. We need to remember these basic principles and how/THAT they pertain outside of just UX
  • “I believe in never making the same mistake twice…Gain as much information from clients and guests.” Videotapes feedback at event

Jeff Dachis

  • @jeffdachis Jeff Dachis is up now talking about User Experience as a Crucial Driver of Social Business Design
  • @leisa I would rephrase: nice to hear so many great speakers (many of whom happen to be female) :)
  • “User experience in the digital world is the key definer value.” That’s what @jeffdachis‘s company is based on
  • @jeffdachis and co developed Social Business Design framework. Understand constituents in biz ecosystem, how they interact
  • @jeffdachis going through the four models of social business design. 1) Ecosystem: from disparate silos to connected nodes
  • 2. Hivemind: from hoarding to collaborating. Willingness to share ideas and connect with one another. Crucial component to success
  • 3. Dynamic signal: from static to dynamic. “Communication as work, not for work.” Twittering isn’t free time, it’s the work itself
  • “Dynamic signal is about process efficiency” Make what used to take hours into just a few minutes by signaling more frequently
  • 4. Metafilter: from filter failure to clear signals. “Finding meaning in all the noise” Filter, tag, sort and make meaning of it all
  • These are the social archetypes that @dachisgroup discusses with their clients.
  • Why social business design? Cost savings & efficiencies, informed social mktg strategies, new product/service offerings/innovations
  • Improved collaborative processes, adaptable business practices, customer growth/retention/sustainability, expansion into new markets
  • “I’m really confident that we can have an impact on commerce, communication and culture. This is a very exciting business to be in.”
  • @gabbyhon sad how buzzwords pay the bills, huh?
  • Wonderful first day at IDEA. Can’t wait to discuss all the things we heard at dinner tonight. Stay tuned to the blog for recap post

Related Posts:

Together we can put humanity back into business

Sign up for my FREE ongoing guidance on how to strengthen your UX practice and design your career. You’ll also receive notifications on my latest blog posts, upcoming speaking engagements, new offerings, recent client projects, and more.


  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by reynish. reynish said: RT & ty to @whitneyhess New blog post: IDEA 2009: Social and Experience Design – Day 1 http://bit.ly/cmZbe Very interesting read […]

  2. […] RSS ← IDEA 2009: Social and Experience Design – Day 1 […]

Leave a Reply