web analytics

IxDA Interaction 09: Day 2

IxDA Interaction 09

My Twitter notes from Interaction 09 Day 2 — Saturday, February 7, 2009 — are below. I have gathered my tweets from Day 1 and Day 3 in other posts.

Saturday Opening Remarks

Keynote: Irrational Behavior by Robert Fabricant

  • This morning’s keynote: “Irrational Behavior” by frog design’s Robert Fabricant http://interaction09.crowdvine.com/talks/show/2589
  • After yesterday’s A/V problems, Robert Fabricant is asking the audience to pray to the Keynote gods that his presentation works
  • Does Robert Fabricant have a Twitter account?
  • “Technology is not our medium. Behavior is our medium.” — Robert Fabricant. Nice!
  • “Data visualization is something that seems to be encoded in our genes as interaction designers. Where does that come from?”
  • Fabricant recently found an old family tree that he drew a long time ago. An artifact at his first attempts at interaction design
  • Now his young daughter is creating think maps at school. In the center: things in my life. Node: Pet -> bunny (daddy may be allergic)
  • Fabricant works on a variety of data viz problems at frog, some interactive (website), some not (billboard).
  • Fabricant spent a year and a half sketching designs for a device that monitors stress levels, displays moments of high stress.
  • Fabricant going through a bunch of devices that reveal data that we’re implicitly creating every day, provides read outs
  • As he sees a preponderance of these devices, he asks himself if this is good interaction design. How do we know?
  • “Numbers and graphs aren’t everything. How do we bring some poetry to it?” Metaphors in the design…hard to find the right one tho
  • He started thinking about cigarettes — there’s something about them that motivates people to use them. How can we do that in ixd?
  • Hard to get people to change their behavior, especially something they do often. Easier to change the non-human parts of the system
  • Understanding how unconscious behavior works can work to our advantage. Fabricant showing a urinal, a power outlet. It’s perception
  • Fabricant is showing “Suspended” sculpture at Storm King. I love this piece! http://is.gd/iKw3
  • Find ways to bring consequences closer. Like warnings on cigarettes, there could be photos of fat people on the Big Mac carton
  • Fabricant mentioning http://www.ambientdevices.com/cat/index.html devices with reward systems built in. Just a small star motivates
  • We need to think about how to motivate people as much as how to warn them. National Debt clock: http://is.gd/iKxL
  • Project in healthcare information: how do you make info salient and simple? It’s about emotional state, bringing consequences closer
  • We get a lot further when we compare ourselves to other people. Social features help surface consequences of behavior
  • is in the top 10 trending topics on Twitter! http://tinyurl.com/ap2kcf
  • Fabricant talking about Purity Balls: http://is.gd/3qca I’ve never heard of this before! “This is powerful design”
  • Despite purity balls, pregnancy rates among evangelical Christians is the highest in the country. It’s having a negative impact
  • Outputs vs. Outcomes vs. Impacts. I love this. Outcome = people are buying. Impact = behavior is changing. There’s a BIG difference
  • Fabricant talking about frog’s project using mobile technology to fight HIV and TB http://is.gd/h5c9
  • Fabricant going into detail about Project Masiluleke
  • Big applause for Robert Fabricant who did a great job inspiring the audience while still making it all relevant to interaction design

Session: Design by Community – The Drupal.org redesign by Leisa Reichelt

  • There is no wi-fi at Hotel Vancouver so I’m Twittering via BlackBerry. @leisa‘s “Design By Community” session about to start
  • While A/V gets ready, @leisa is doing a stand-up routine. She’s hilarious! (All Brits are, aren’t they?)
  • @leisa worked on the redesign of http://drupal.org. Their community is incredibly active and opinionated, were involved in redesign
  • Drupal is an open source content management framework. 300,000 users. Redesigning around active users is a unique challenge
  • Rearchitecting is like rebuilding a city around the people already living there. And the Drupal community are the builders
  • Not designing Drupal in an open source way seemed counterintuitive, was obvious to include the community. Oppt’y to showcase process
  • This sounds an awful lot like my work with @boxee. This is great!
  • Project guidelines: 1-Bake community into the process. 2-Be open source like. 3-Transfer skills & knowledge. 4-When in doubt, share.
  • @leisa started off by doing interviews at a Drupal conference. Got embedded in project so quickly, face-to-face with existing users
  • Ditched early ideas about remote research tools. Too cumbersome. Instead relied heavily on Twitter. “Anti-echo chamber”
  • Used Twitter as recruiting tool for research participation. Twitter Search from drupal revealed community’s gripes
  • Did online card sorts to prove that “Drupal speak” was not understood by the general community
  • Weekly user research reviews on the blog. @drupalredesign twitter account posting ideas for lightweight feedback. Flickr pool photos
  • @leisa and partner Mark blogged on http://disambiguity.com about the process. Plugged into the drupal community blogs
  • Drafted an experience strategy but @leisa isn’t pleased with it. Didn’t feel they pushed it enough. But recommends doing one at all
  • Crowd-sourced wireframing. Community sent in their own ideas for designs. “We got the wireframe done in 5 min?” Concerns about this..
  • Crowdsourced usability testing. Interesting concept, but very few people participated. @leisa was really the only one doing testing
  • Put Google Analytics on the prototype page. Got 50,000 views.
  • Design by community vs. Design by committee. By community can work. Scale is your friend. Look for trends. Look for the unexpected
  • With 12 stakeholders you have to scratch every person’s itch. With 50,000 “clients” you can’t possibly do what everyone wants=Freedom
  • Don’t relinquish your responsibilities as a designer. “Design is no place for democracy”. More than ever designer needs to take lead
  • Comm feedback was intense. They annotated screenshots, designed pages themselves. But @leisa ultimately had the research. They didn’t
  • “Social/communication skills are almost as important as design skills”. Respect comm, bake them into process. Token gestures useless
  • If you do a project like this, you *will* underestimate the amount of time you should be spending with the community.
  • Provide a focus for discussion. That will yield better feedback, more value.
  • Give the community time to work it out amongst themselves. Wait before getting involved
  • Ignore flaming comments (unless it’s a trend). Don’t be defensive. Don’t take it personally.
  • Choose battles. But you should be wrong, sometimes. Don’t feel like you always have to be right. You won’t have thought of everything
  • This kind of work is not for everybody. It’s terribly scary. You need a support network. But it’s totally worth it. It matters
  • I asked @leisa how they ensured that they weren’t optimizing the design to the outliers (noisy community members). She said they…
  • …prioritizing their own research over the community feedback. So sounds to me like this is more selling to comm than designing with
  • Great session! Can’t wait to talk to @leisa later about the @boxee process

Session: Designing Natural Interfaces by Nathan Moody

  • I’m Twittering from @atomick‘s talk “Designing Natural Interfaces” or NUIs Works with Darren David at http://stimulant.io/
  • NUI vs GUI. NUI has direct manipulation, lower accuracy, etc.
  • Client requests look like…shows photo of Minority Report. Audience laughter
  • Good news: if you want to design NUIs, you already have the skills. @atomick showing it’s a very similar process/deliverables
  • Prototyping and staging more complex because it’s custom hardware. Looks super cool though. 6′ by 18′ rear projection walls
  • Stimulant works with some big name clients. Exciting to see what these companies are exploring these types of interactive experiences
  • Challenges: managing user expectations, facilitating natural and gestural inputs, designing large format/360-degree interactions
  • Managing user expectations: attracting interest, recognizing interactivity, granting permission to touch. Encourage and instruct
  • Microsoft Surface water app is their attract mechanism. “Innate human interest in beauty” Simple app, but extremely successful
  • Smooth jazz just came over the PA system. Fairmont Hotel Vancouver conference FAIL. Props to @atomick for continuing through it
  • Explicit education is fine, but watch how literal and heavy handed you are. Comes off as cheesy
  • Facilitating natural/gestural input: fundamental ergomonics (touchability, control occlusion). Identification w/o a keyboard & mouse
  • Virtual keyboards have high error rates. Try to avoid them.
  • Unlearning GUI habits: never control by proxy when you can control directly. Unfamiliarity clouds expectations. Real vs hyper real
  • @37signals “defensive design” — designing for forgiveness. Don’t ever allow the user to fail. Every single input must be recognized
  • This is beautiful advice for designing all systems, but particularly critical for gestural interfaces which are largely public
  • Key input challenges: whose finger is that? Session mgmt/usage tracking. Accessibility. Virtual keyboards suck
  • Output challenges: humans have narrow scope of vision, so we actually see very little of large screen display
  • Multi-user challenges: context and appropriateness. Collaborative, not competitive. Who has control?
  • Tabletop computing. Users making eye contact across the computer makes for interesting social dynamics. Orientation of content in 360
  • Tabletop computing more comfortable than horizontal screen, new social interactions b/w users. Designing above-the-table interactions
  • Shadows can be used to determine directionality, figure out if both hands belong to the same person. That’s freakin cool
  • @atomick showing some examples of Stimulant’s designs for Microsoft Surface. TouchTones Music Sequencer. XRay iPhone mashup
  • The work that Stimulant is doing is so far out. I really wanna get involved with this!
  • Reference list: Designing Interactions, Bill Moggridge. Designing Gestural Interfaces, Dan Saffer. http://NUIgroup.com

Session: Weathering the current economic climate: A group conversation by Josh Seiden

  • I’m Twittering from @jseiden‘s “Weathering the Current Economic Climate: A Group Conversation” — my old boss!
  • I’m Twittering on behalf of @boxesandarrows http://boxesandarrows.com The best peer-written journal on UX, IxD and IA
  • @jseiden put two big pieces of paper on the wall and had us put post-its up. Questions on one. What I Can Speak To on the other
  • Starting with Questions. “Are we really worse off now?” @ebacon says her leads are drying up. Others saying greater demand for design
  • @emenel: companies’ budgets drying up so instead of using agencies they’re using independent consultants. Several experiencing this
  • Senior management is starting to believe more in the importance of user experience. Quality is more important than ever
  • @joshviney says his company http://eastmedia.com is selling more of the design craft. Echoing the focus on quality & expertise
  • Audience member saying she now has a greater opportunity to get involved in customer experience issues, really fulfilling work
  • Q to the audience: who’s finding a shift in how they sell their services, or what they can sell?
  • I said that I’m finding companies are more willing to try new methods to solve problems, more open to discover the real problem
  • Interaction designers finding themselves on the frontlines of business when our client contacts are no longer employed there.
  • @jseiden – “This is a learning moment for us.” You’re not just an IxD anymore, you’re also a PM, a business analyst, a developer, etc
  • “I wouldn’t call this a time of crisis; I’d call this a time of transition.” — @emenel Whole new industries are opening up to IxDers
  • Wow, the session is already over. @jseiden reading off the “What I can speak to” board so that people can connect afterwards

Session: Sketching haptic and multimodal interaction by Camille Moussette

  • I’m Twittering from Camille Moussette’s “Sketching haptic and multimodal interaction” http://is.gd/iM60 http://www.guchmu.com/
  • Camille is a getting a Ph.D. in mobile haptic interfaces at the Ume√• Institute of Design in Sweden http://www.dh.umu.se/
  • “We’re living in a world where our senses are constantly stimulated.” Camille focuses on the “touch” sense, not as explored
  • Haptic technology is not touchscreen. It’s when you apply forces back to the user to create some stimulation. iPhone is a poor haptic
  • Haptic perception is a combination of somatosensory perception on the skin and proprioception (sense of one’s limbs in space)
  • Haptic perception is *active* touch; interaction is often multimodal (visual and auditory cues). Natural overlap of sound & vibration
  • Grounded interfaces have a base to which you apply forces. Ungrounded interfaces, like a phone, are free floating, no foundation
  • Prototypes = filters that traverse a design space & are manifestations of design ideas that concretize & externalize conceptual ideas
  • That’s a quote from The Anatomy of Prototypes: http://tinyurl.com/bapys9
  • Sketching/prototyping haptics is a challenge but a necessity. Mistakes are even more costly. We have limited vocab about touch sense
  • You should be following @kaleemux who is sitting next to me in this session
  • Vicrotactile devices: audio and haptic vibration recreates lots of surfaces like walking on snow, water, slippery surfaces
  • That was Vibrotactile..
  • Force feedback systems like gaming steering wheels http://tinyurl.com/cdhsdy
  • Distributed tactile displays: http://is.gd/iMaB
  • Camille showing a variety of prototyping techniques for haptic devices based on the length of your timeline.
  • Challenge is describing haptic stimuli and verbalizing sensations. Synthesizing movement/haptic feedback not trivial.
  • Camille has so much great info packed into his slides. This session should have been longer. Lightning sessions are TOO SHORT!
  • Multimodality: available in parallel (user’s pref or context) or fused (data fixed or adaptive). Context influences modalities used
  • OpenInterface project: http://openinterface.org “Focuses on human-human & human-machine natural interaction, physical/virtual enviro”

Keynote: Carpe Diem: Attention, Awareness, and Interaction Design 2009 by Dan Saffer

  • I’m Twittering from @odannyboy‘s keynote “Carpe Diem: Attention, Awareness, and Interaction Design in 2009″ http://is.gd/iMjg
  • @odannyboy just played the passing-the-ball moonwalking-bear video: http://tinyurl.com/2zwhrf
  • Now he’s showing the longest threads of 2008 on IxDA mailing list http://ixda.org/discuss Hard to believe this is what we talk about
  • @odannyboy going to tell us what we should be paying attention to. Not just problems. Twitter didn’t solve any problems
  • Design is also about invention. “We’re not just janitors mopping up the problems of businesses.” — @odannyboy
  • New subjects of design: healthcare, education, government, energy, services, organizations
  • In 1995: Intel 486 cost ~$1,500. In 2009: costs less than 50 cents. More computing power in this room than in existence 10 years ago
  • Near future (really now) fields for us to focus on: ubicomp, software agents, wearables, robots, green technology
  • New interaction design paradigms: gestures, voice, touch. I think we’ve been seeing this quite clearly with @interaction09‘s sessions
  • “We can create the paradigms for the next 40 years right now.” — @odannyboy
  • @odannyboy asked Adam Greenfield what he thinks our challenges are: “Making the visible invisible, and the invisible visible.”
  • “How we live is slowly destroying the planet. We’re doing the damage bit by bit and switch by switch…but I’m hopeful” — @odannyboy
  • @odannyboy has a slide up right now that just says, “It’s the economy, stupid.”
  • “Don’t despair, not even over the fact that you don’t despair.” — Franz Kafka
  • “We need a buildup. We need to get back to making stuff.” — Thomas Friedman. @odannyboy says we need *responsible* buildup
  • “I’m not afraid of storms, for I am learning how to sail my ship.” — Louisa May Alcott
  • @odannyboy says: RESIST THE “DEFINING INTERACTION DESIGN” DISCUSSIONS. Huge applause from the audience. HOOT HOOT
  • Move *between* the frames. They’re religious wars. Be flexible, determine what is best for the project. “There are no best practices”
  • “Best practices should be a place to begin, not where it ends” — @odannyboy “Instead of ‘design thinking’ let’s think *and* make”
  • “Stop fetishing simplicity.” “Don’t forget that for most, the interface is the system.” The faucet is not the water system
  • @russu hmmm where have I heard that one before… ;)
  • Follow the emotion. We have to create products that people are emotionally invested in. The more invested, the more valuable
  • It sometimes benefits us to be more like artists than scientists. They’re hiring us, a designer not an MBA
  • “Nobody gets excited about a wireframe.” – David Verba If your docs look like other ppl in room can do them, why are they hiring you?
  • Steal from movies (glamour), biology (natural ecosystems), architecture (language of space). Look to the past for inspiration
  • Was just the 40th anniversary of Doug Englebart’s Mother of All Demos: http://tinyurl.com/s3hlu
  • “The future is not Google-able” We have no idea what the future is going to be, we can only help bring it about
  • @odannyboy IxDA should make interaction design stars! Where are our Gehrys and Philippe Starks? We need to stop being anonymous
  • “We need to stop waiting for permission.” — @odannyboy
  • “You already know everything you need to know to design for the future.” This is so true. Stop second-guessing yourselves
  • “May tomorrow be more uncertain than today.” — Deepak Chopra Nightly prayer that he has his children say
  • This is a really inspirational talk. Reminds me of @inkblurt‘s closing plenary at IA Summit 2008

Related Posts:

Together we can put humanity back into business

Sign up for my FREE ongoing guidance on how to strengthen your UX practice and design your career. You’ll also receive notifications on my latest blog posts, upcoming speaking engagements, new offerings, recent client projects, and more.


  1. […] Day 3 — Sunday, February 8, 2009 — are below. I have gathered my tweets from Day 1 and Day 2 in other […]

  2. […] 09 Day 1 — Friday, February 6, 2009 — are below. I have gathered my tweets from Day 2 and Day 3 in other […]

  3. […] the people who are responsible for paying your salary or invoice. They can’t be ignored. As Whitney Hess tweeted and then blogged, they have itches that need to be […]

Leave a Reply