web analytics

IDEA Conference 2008: Day 2

This is a continuation of my coverage from the IDEA Conference in Chicago from October 7-8, 2008. My Day 1 roundup can be found here.

The speakers from Day 2 were Chris Crawford, Alberto Cañas, Jason Fried, Aradhana Goel, Bill DeRouchey and Andrew Hinton.

Let’s get right to it…

Chris Crawford: “Linguistic User Interfaces”

  • Chris Crawford, game designer, says he’s been living in the mountains for the past 10 years
  • Sapir-whorf hypothesis: inside the human mind, language & reality are closely connected.
  • Since a computer cannot hold reality, it can’t really hold language. It’s actually more toy-like.
  • Crawford says first q you ask when designing software: “What does the user DO?” Not what do they see.
  • Actual number of verbs in software relates to how powerful it is. Verbs need to be accessible. Count the # that ppl actually use
  • Ratio of accessible verbs to actual verbs would equal 1 in an ideal world
  • Expectable verbs = the expectations created by the model. When you set expectations w one element, user expects it to be repeated
  • Chris Crawford is an animated and emphatic speaker. Perfect for the first session after a late night of drinking
  • Graphical user interface puts the verbs right in front of your face. Accessible : Actual is near 1. Actual : Expectable is near 1
  • GUIs fall short when the verb count gets too high. More levels of hierarchy reduce the Accessible and increase the Expectable
  • GUIs aren’t effective above ~100 verbs. But as we march forward into the future, we want to offer more and more verbs. Problem.
  • The Little Mermaid is 22 pages at 36 point font. It’s 122 unique verbs. “That’s a pro-level application”
  • Interactive storytelling requires thousands of verbs. GUIs don’t cut it. “We need a linguistic user interface” — Chris Crawford
  • 25,000 typical words in the English vocab. If storyworld requires 1,000 words then Actual:Expectable=.4 Bad!
  • Inverse parser = presenting options to user for them to select in a given context
  • Chris Crawford is throwing his voice
  • “Dramatic context” ;)
  • Context limits available options, reduces size of menus. Makes it more usable
  • Chris Crawford demoing storybook madlibs-type interface
  • Crawford demoing Storytron’s Storyworld Authoring Tool (Swat). Creates dramatic possibilities
  • The courage to err: oral communication rife w ambiguity. Expect contextual ambiguity, users will resolve. Move them along quickly.
  • Error rates can be high. But that’s ok. What’s actually important is the ratio of correct to incorrect. Get it mostly right
  • Our own immune system gets it wrong a lot. It makes guesses based on limited information. But it responds quickly, it’s aggressive
  • Chris Crawford: “Death to CYA!” (cover your ass) Have the courage to make mistakes, but respond quickly. Requires lotsa processing
  • Chris Crawford rocked. I really enjoyed that. Now my head is spinning

Alberto Cañas: “CmapTools: From Meaningful Learning to a Network of Knowledge Builders”

  • Dr. Alberto Cañas, Co-founder and asst director of Institute for Human and Machine Cognition
  • Not a designer, marketer or business person (@armano asked for show of hands before his talk yesterday). Cañas is a researcher
  • Institute for Human and Machine Cognition (IHMC) made up of computer scientists, psychologists, physicians, engineers, etc
  • IHMC all about researching machine learning. 2nd most sensible organ in your body is your tongue. Could allow blind ppl to “see”
  • Designing human-centered flight displays through greater understanding of peripheral vision. Provide feedback in new ways
  • Cmap Tools software developed to allow users to create and share concept models.
  • Artificial flight: Is it feathers or the beak? Can we really recreate the experience w/o getting naked? Birds don’t wear clothes
  • Our bone structure is different than a bird’s, etc. But once you understand theory of aerodynamics then you can make things fly
  • The web comes along & what do we do? We put a page on it. Why? Because we were used to looking @ pages. Like wearing a beak to fly
  • You need to understand the *theory* in order to create new systems. “Concept maps facilitate the explicit expression of knowledge”
  • “I still don’t know what you all do, and from what I can tell neither do you” — Alberto Cañas to the audience
  • “Knowledge isn’t only concepts. It’s propositions, units of meaning or claims. Relationships between two concepts” Brilliant!
  • A theory of learning: each person constructs their own meanings for concepts and propositions from experience over time
  • But you have to WANT to learn!
  • Children have better understanding of concepts than adults do. Children can tell you so much, they’re absorbing it all
  • “Meaningful learning is innate” — Alberto Cañas
  • Linking phrases: “is necessary for,” “is based on,” “facilitates the,” “can build” etc etc
  • Concept maps are also an interesting way to navigate tons of info on a subject. Provides multiple entry points and reduces noise
  • Alberto Cañas talking about a project he worked on creating concept maps with students in Panama. Too much to capture here
  • Read about it here: http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2005/05/67685

Jason Fried: “Getting Real”

  • @jasonfried is up now! No slides. Talking for 15 minutes and then doing Q&A
  • @jasonfried is cofounder of @37signals for those two of you who don’t know
  • They don’t plan: no personas, flowcharts, anything. They’re “holdovers from other disciplines.” They build & figure it out as we go
  • All those artifacts are abstractions. They allude to “an illusion of agreement”
  • They sketch with thick markers. Random ideas of what you can do through the interface. Pencils/pens are too high resolution
  • “Epicenter of design”: they focus on the one thing on the page that must exist. Then they ask what else this could possibly need
  • “We figure out what to put on the page by using it.” They are their own users [but not all software can be designed that way!]
  • The longer it takes you to develop something, the less likely it becomes that you’ll ever release it
  • Get feedback from real people who use your product. Start with a simple core, then improve
  • Interruptions prevent us from actually getting anything done. No one works during the day anymore. They work @ night & on weekends
  • @37signals has 12 ppl & don’t all work out of same office b/c it’s just distracting. They use passive collaboration on group chat
  • Audience Q: “can I have a job?” Audience laughter
  • “Hire only when it hurts, when you can’t do it anymore… And don’t hire a job you haven’t done yourself before” — @jasonfried
  • Audience Q: “How do you use ‘Getting Real’ with clients?” @jasonfried: Most of the process stuff is bullshit
  • When they were doing web design, they never offered 3 design solutions. They delivered one. The right design
  • “Not every client will be receptive to that, but you don’t have to hire them. Remember that you’re hiring your clients, too”
  • If you don’t have a good fit with the client, then neither of you will ever be happy with the work. Find the right match
  • If you present 2 designs, one good & one bad, the client is going to pick the bad one. So don’t show them something you don’t like
  • Meetings are expensive. 1hr mtg is really only 1hr if only 1 person is in the room. 5ppl, 5hrs. 10ppl, 10hrs. Losing productivity
  • Demand respect from your clients. Don’t be afraid to fight back. You wouldn’t tell the plumber how to fix the toilet– @jasonfried
  • “We’re always scratching our own itch. We’re not special. We’re a small biz. If we need it, hundreds of companies do too”
  • What’s your perspective on competitive analysis? “We don’t pay attention to the competition. We pay attention to the customers”
  • 10yrs ago successful software meant big shelf space. Advantage now “The Internet is the biggest shelf there ever was” @jasonfried

Aradhana Goel: “Emerging trends | Design thinking | Service innovation”

  • “We all believe in human-centered design. We all believe that when it comes to design empathy is key” – Aradhana Goel
  • She has seen design challenges evolve from tangible to intangible, permanent to temporal, reactive to predictive
  • More and more at IDEO she’s been dealing with projects that are very open-ended. “We’re 2nd in marketplace. How do we become 1st?”
  • “Open challenges require a fundamental shift in where we look. Not only need empathy for indiv, but also get pulse of collective”
  • What are the trend factors? Societal, technology, business
  • Societal: shifts in cultural landscape, patterns of behavioral change, connections between domains
  • Technology enablers: state of the art, new potential opportunities, patterns of adoption
  • Business trends: changing the value equation, emerging and established revenue models, stakeholder ecosystems
  • “Trends are temporal by definition…In today’s very nimble world, one year is like a lifetime.” – Goel
  • Goel showing a mosaic of her Facebook friends and I know some of those people!
  • Examples of “culture of networks” trend: http://GreenNote.com Amex’s http://membersproject.com
  • Trend: nomadism. Parasitic living. Seamless transitions b/w contexts. “Today everything is living in the cloud…we’re untethered”
  • She couldn’t find a really good example of nomadism trend but is working on some now. http://CitizenM.com is a close example
  • Trend: conscientious consumption. Sustainable living. Physical scarcity and digital abundance.
  • Goel is brilliant. A true synthesist. All this stuff that’s been floating around in my head is perfectly articulated on the slide
  • Examples of conscientious consumption: Toyota-Prius and Zipcar
  • “They say green is the new black”
  • Technology trends: platform approach. No killer application. Choice and flexibility.
  • Tech trend: Adaptive Services. Evolutionary. Customization over time. “Over time they become you.” Netflix, Amazon, Pandora
  • Multi-channel conversations. New paradigm of customer service. Twitter accounts for @Zappos @comcastcares @southwestair
  • Trend: free! Redefining value for commodities. Skype, Flickr, Nokia-CWM
  • Trend: crowd-sourcing. Distributive co-creation. Open Innovation. Zappos, Best Buy, Air New Zealand
  • Zappos has a guidebook for how to provide service to customers. But it’s not written from the top down; it’s written by employees
  • Trend: micro transactions as applied to emerging markets. Micro-lending. M-Pesa, Grameen bank, Kiva. [I hope you’re participating]
  • @milewis just tweeted that you can request a copy of the Zappos customer service guidebook just by emailing them!
  • Human factors (user interviews, observations, extreme users) + Trend factors (media audits, era analysis, expert panels)
  • Trend factors is finding the context and Human factors is digging into context. Complementary approaches, no one or the other
  • Projects that helped Goel realize all this. 1) “Design a converged services portfolio for a siloed organization”
  • 2) “Make mobile phone top of the wallet (financial tool)”. 3) “Design concepts for the future of retail banking (beyond 2015)”

[Download Aradhana’s slides]

Bill DeRouchey: “The Language of Interaction”

  • @billder is a Senior Interaction Designer at Ziba Design
  • “The Language of Interaction” No matter what we call ourselves, we’re designing some kind of interface that people use
  • What can we actually learn from the objects that we have to do alone? Remotes, for example.
  • @billder wants to draw from previous sessions, especially Chris Crawford’s and @armano’s
  • Past experiences affect our future expectations. A triangle is just a triangle until it’s turned sideways, then it’s a Play button
  • The @ symbol denotes much more than it ever did before. Email, Twitter, etc. Or as @mediajunkie yelled out: “whitney hess”
  • “We need to see what people see” so it can inform out designs. Seek inspiration outside of technology.
  • Seek inspiration from common interactions like ATMs. Or from what amuses us, like gas pumps.
  • Inspiration from what scares the hell out of us. Ticket machine at the Metro in DC
  • The more people see things the more they’ll expect to see them, so we need to be aware of it. “We create and curate this language”
  • Meaning migrates across domains. Meaning can evolve. TV sports: arrow pointed to team w possession. Now labeled “possession arrow”
  • We need to decode the language of interaction in order to be able to use it. Elements, relationships, principles
  • Fridge interface: instead of up and down arrows for temp, “warmer” & “cooler.” But then they added “TurboCool” and “ExpressChill”
  • Ppl are used to seeing things in zones. We do it w/o realizing. Consider Amazon. We auto ignore in certain areas we think are ads
  • Clarity. If everyone calls it “sleep” on an alarm, why change it to “repeat alarm”?
  • Weatherband button has a divot so you can get to it faster. Makes sense in hurricane or tornado areas. Geographically-based button
  • Clarity: anticipate the question. Measuring cups that display the size in big bold letters
  • Muxtape‘s big bold letters on song titles. “RIP Muxtape” — @billder
  • @billder’s microwave forces him to set the date. There’s no possible reason why a microwave could need to know the date
  • So many buttons on a remote. Are all these things really necessary?
  • Designing for surprise & delight. Parking lot in Portland tells you of spaces in each direction. Green light above open spots

Bill DeRouchey’s slides:

The Language of Interaction
View SlideShare presentation or Upload your own. (tags: ixd ixda)

Andrew Hinton: “You are (Mostly) Here: Digital Space and the Context Problem”

  • Let’s say Vegas provides a new service: you’re going to be watched everywhere you spend $ and it’ll be shared w/ your peeps
  • You wouldn’t like it very much. Well that’s basically what Facebook did with Beacon.
  • There was mass revolt against Beacon and it hurt Facebook’s brand. Why did it happen? FB didn’t take time to get to know the users
  • @inkblurt showing a photo of a urinal that Marcel Duchamp submitted to a gallery. He was challenging all preconceived notions
  • Labels affect our perception. @inkblurt showing this image
  • @inkblurt asks: If 5 ppl were on a track & the train was coming, would you pull the lever to save 5 if it would kill 1 person?
  • Power of context in language. Context is somewhat biological and when ppl hear this question you can see reaction in the brain
  • Maps are archetypal way of how people form contexts. Map (language), territory (context)
  • RT @kaleemux: Showing 10 different maps of Boylan Heights in the context of power lines, parking spaces, water, street signs, etc
  • Multi-user domain (MUD) In digital space, map creates the territory! No physical space to look at
  • Fuzzy boundaries between real and virtual. Google results for “leatherworking” giving directions to build World of Warcraft garb
  • Ppl in the audience are on their comps, Twittering, emailing, blogging, while listening. We rarely do one thing at a time anymore
  • Fuzzy human stuff is being made into data. Like matters of the heart translated to “relationship status” on Facebook
  • @inkblurt using “Eats Shoots and Leaves” example to illustrate context created by one comma :)
  • D vs @ on Twitter. Really easy to make the mistake (as we all know). Hitting Reply All on an email when you really didn’t want to
  • “We’re now offered a plethora of choices & places that each has its own architecture that shapes your identity when you’re there”
  • Sherry Turkle: “Real life is just one more window”
  • Information Architecture is about language and context informing each other — @inkblurt
  • @inkblurt wrapping up with Qs now. @mmilan asks: how do we evangelize the practice while we’re still sharpening the language?
  • @inkblurt says we do top-down and bottom-up approaches simultaneously.
  • What about emotional contexts that users bring to our software/sites? It does add friction & we have to try to be aware of them
  • @inkblurt is too smart for me

[Download Andrew’s slides]

[Podcasts of all talks can be found on Boxes and Arrows]

Related Posts:

Together we can put humanity back into business

Sign up for my FREE ongoing guidance on how to strengthen your UX practice and design your career. You’ll also receive notifications on my latest blog posts, upcoming speaking engagements, new offerings, recent client projects, and more.


  1. If anyone is looking for a highly skilled and professional Organic Search Engine Optimization Firm, we can assist you, please call 602-404-4444 or visit us online at http://www.directconnectcommunications.com


  1. […] ← Who coined the term “wireframes”? IDEA Conference 2008: Day 2 […]

Leave a Reply